FANDOM


  • Just a little idea I've got ^^

    We know that - at the origin - they wanted Colin, Lana, Robert AND JMO to return as series regular for S7. And we all know how it ended.

    However, what if JMO agreed to come back as series regular? She'd prolly play a cursed version of Emma in Hyperion Heights too.


    My idea? Let's discuss of our theories about that! What do you think Emma could have been/done if she was regular during S7? Who would be her cursed persona in HH?

    Of course, we have to admit that the rest of the context/events is the same: Henry is the main point of the season, with Cinderella, Lucy, Lady Tremaine, Roni, Rogers, Weaver, etc...

    To make it simple: the S7 as it is now, but with Emma as regular :)

    I'm really curious about our ideas and theories ^^

      Preparing Editor Spell
    • I'd say we wouldn't have Wish Realm Hook or his daughter. If his daughter is Rapunzel (to be introduced later theoretically), then she may not appear on the show or would have a different role. If it's Alice, Tremaine, or Jacinda (as has been suggested, though I doubt it) they would have different backstories. Or maybe Wish Realm Hook would still appear, but die, and then Hook and Emma stick around in the NEF to find his daughter for him?

      Emma would have a Hyperion Heights counterpart. I like the name Scarlet for her (for the jacket) with some duck- or princess-themed surname (or she could have Rogers' surname). Maybe she could be a doctor -- that would tie into the whole "Savior" thing pretty well.

      I wonder if Scarlet and Rogers would be married or if they'd be separated like Snow and Charming were. Maybe divorced? Then we get some romantic tension as long as they're cursed. (As soon as the curse breaks, of course, they'd get back together).

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I think she would be married to Rogers and would be a cop too. 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • She could be a detective with rogers, work with roni as a bartender. Maybe she could be a bailsbondsmen lol. She could own a store perhaps. I just wished she stayed. There definitely not going to have WR Hook if she stayed but hook would definitely be the same though. I don't think she be married though but her memories will probably be similar to how they were during the first curse or before the second curse

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I have a feeling, the story would have been fairly similar. Only that the missing girl, who may or may not be Rapunzel, would have been Emma and (real) Hook's daughter.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I think they would have been separated by the curse like Snowing and we would have seen them fall in love all over again. I would have liked for them to be detective partners that solved cases together and for those cases to be connected to Tremaine/Belfrey, which would have helped bring her down. Cursed Emma would also be a single mother to a young daughter, but Cursed Killian is  a father figure to her. The daughter is best friends with Lucy. 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Emma and Hook would be cursed. Hook would be the cop Rogers. Not sure what Emma's job would be, but her last name would be Cygnus.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Raymondnoodles
      Raymondnoodles removed this reply because:
      Re edit
      04:19, October 15, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • CoolDudeAl wrote: Emma and Hook would be cursed. Hook would be the cop Rogers. Not sure what Emma's job would be, but her last name would be Cygnus.

      Why do you think her last name would be that?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • And I forgot to say something earlier but Emma could take roni's place and Regina would probably do something else

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Raymondnoodles wrote:

      CoolDudeAl wrote: Emma and Hook would be cursed. Hook would be the cop Rogers. Not sure what Emma's job would be, but her last name would be Cygnus.

      Why do you think her last name would be that?

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swan

      Read the first sentence of that article and you'll see why.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • In my opinion, they would continued with Storybrooke as usual and come up with a reason why Snow & Charming aren't there like going back to the Enchanted Forest. This whole reboot is because they lost their main character and they needed to refocus on a different main character which is Henry as adult.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Farerb wrote:
      In my opinion, they would continued with Storybrooke as usual and come up with a reason why Snow & Charming aren't there like going back to the Enchanted Forest. This whole reboot is because they lost their main character and they needed to refocus on a different main character which is Henry as adult.


      Reboot is in preparation since one year. And that's not the discussion here. I asked what if Emma was a part of the S7 as it is currently ^^

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • ChocolatEyes613
      ChocolatEyes613 removed this reply because:
      double post
      15:02, October 15, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • ChocolatEyes613
      ChocolatEyes613 removed this reply because:
      double post
      15:02, October 15, 2017
      This reply has been removed
    • Farerb wrote: In my opinion, they would continued with Storybrooke as usual and come up with a reason why Snow & Charming aren't there like going back to the Enchanted Forest. This whole reboot is because they lost their main character and they needed to refocus on a different main character which is Henry as adult.

      The show has been in desperate need of a reboot for a while. Fans have been saying, for years, that Henry should be aged up. The problem is that may have come too late. Emma Swan was originally meant to be apart of it, and it is fairly obvious the storyline would have been similar to S1!Snowing and Wish!Hook's.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Farerb wrote:
      In my opinion, they would continued with Storybrooke as usual and come up with a reason why Snow & Charming aren't there like going back to the Enchanted Forest. This whole reboot is because they lost their main character and they needed to refocus on a different main character which is Henry as adult.

      Weren't Andrew and Alison cast before the contracts were signed?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • DatNuttyKid wrote:
      Farerb wrote:
      In my opinion, they would continued with Storybrooke as usual and come up with a reason why Snow & Charming aren't there like going back to the Enchanted Forest. This whole reboot is because they lost their main character and they needed to refocus on a different main character which is Henry as adult.
      Weren't Andrew and Alison cast before the contracts were signed?

      We would have Henry and Lucy anyway. If they wanted JMo and Lana as Emma and Regina, it's obvious Henry would be back. And if they didn't wanted Jared, it's obvious they would recast him.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • But he’s still in flashbacks though.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • If Emma stayed, I believe I would have a peace of mind because then some of the answers would be more clear to me

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • 123Raura wrote:
      If Emma stayed, I believe I would have a peace of mind because then some of the answers would be more clear to me

      They already said they would explain character's absences, you just have to give them time. They can't cover everything in one episode.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • If she stayed then wouldn't Lucy be replace by Emma & Killian's child to get Henry to break the curse?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • If Jennifer Morrison stayed I don’t think they would have done another curse but had just chronicled the events in the NEF with Henry, Hook, and Rumple. Then, at the end of the season, she has her child.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • They likely had already written -- or at least planned -- the finale when they found out that Jen wasn't coming back, so I'd say anything set up in that episode would be included no matter what (Lucy as Henry's kid, grown-up Henry, the curse, etc.)

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Emma would be a wanted criminal whom Rogers intends to capture.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Avatar Beta wrote:
      Emma would be a wanted criminal whom Rogers intends to capture.

      Why? Wouldn't they put Emma on the force if she were cursed. She is technically a bail bonds person/certified sheriff. I know she wouldn't remember being the Savior (Damn, who is the freakin' Savoir in Lil Driz's curse anyway? It can't be Henry. He has no magic ... But this means, whoever breaks the curse will be unexpected!) But Driz would have the Hyperion Citizens doing stuff that's familiar - i.e. Weaver does hardcore detective stuff and acts as if he owns the place, much like Gold; Regina gives out life advice with her empowering speech, similar to how she used to be mayor of Storybrooke ... and since Reg is gone from Storybrooke, I'm guessing, Storybrooke is a literal utopia because of the happily ever afters, and now the Charmings are the mayors? Henry is is an author, like how he's in control of the storybook of fairytales, which is why he can't break the curse. He doesn't have the magic to do so. 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Jennifer leaving had nothing to do with the new direction. I refuse to call Season 7 a reboot when it isn't even close to a reboot. Exact same characters and Universe is being used. History of the main Characters remain the same. Minus a few main characters leaving but that doesn't make it a reboot by anymeans. 


      Also Henry has magic as he is the author and has the Heart of the Truest believer which is a powerful source of Magic. This was explained during Season 3 and 4. Either way though Emma didn't break Regina's curse due to her magic but the true loves kiss shared between her and Henry. 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • KnocknickKnock wrote:
      Jennifer leaving had nothing to do with the new direction. I refuse to call Season 7 a reboot when it isn't even close to a reboot. Exact same characters and Universe is being used. History of the main Characters remain the same. Minus a few main characters leaving but that doesn't make it a reboot by anymeans. 


      Also Henry has magic as he is the author and has the Heart of the Truest believer which is a powerful source of Magic. This was explained during Season 3 and 4. Either way though Emma didn't break Regina's curse due to her magic but the true loves kiss shared between her and Henry. 

      Some truest believer he's been in Hyperion heights.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Anonymius wrote:
      KnocknickKnock wrote:
      Jennifer leaving had nothing to do with the new direction. I refuse to call Season 7 a reboot when it isn't even close to a reboot. Exact same characters and Universe is being used. History of the main Characters remain the same. Minus a few main characters leaving but that doesn't make it a reboot by anymeans. 


      Also Henry has magic as he is the author and has the Heart of the Truest believer which is a powerful source of Magic. This was explained during Season 3 and 4. Either way though Emma didn't break Regina's curse due to her magic but the true loves kiss shared between her and Henry. 

      Some truest believer he's been in Hyperion heights.

      Ditto to that. In all fairness, I'm rooting for Anastasia to be the one who break the curse(thisisscreweduprightnow)

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I'm also rooting for an adaption of Anastasia Romanov into the show. It would be ... different.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • 123Raura wrote:
      Anonymius wrote:
      KnocknickKnock wrote:
      Jennifer leaving had nothing to do with the new direction. I refuse to call Season 7 a reboot when it isn't even close to a reboot. Exact same characters and Universe is being used. History of the main Characters remain the same. Minus a few main characters leaving but that doesn't make it a reboot by anymeans. 


      Also Henry has magic as he is the author and has the Heart of the Truest believer which is a powerful source of Magic. This was explained during Season 3 and 4. Either way though Emma didn't break Regina's curse due to her magic but the true loves kiss shared between her and Henry. 

      Some truest believer he's been in Hyperion heights.
      Ditto to that. In all fairness, I'm rooting for Anastasia to be the one who break the curse(thisisscreweduprightnow)

      I'm thinking it will be like in season 1, with henry kissing Lucy to break the curse (cos it seems despite Drizilla apparently learning from past experiences with the curse she hasn't considered that it doesn't need to be Henry and Jacinda kissing to break the curse especially considering it wasn't a romantic kiss that broke the first curse.).

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • With Emma the was curse. She will might think she marry to Roger. She is a babysitter for lucy to earn money. Probably she not has a curse name. The real hook think he has a twin brother.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Yuma10000 wrote:
      With Emma the was curse. She will might think she marry to Roger. She is a babysitter for lucy to earn money. Probably she not has a curse name. The real hook think he has a twin brother.

      They could name her Anna.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Any new ideas on how this would've been now that the season is over?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I'm conflicted as to whether or not Alice would have been Emma and Hook's kid because I'm not sure what the timeline would be if she was, but otherwise it seems pretty reasonable.

      Besides that, I still like the idea of Emma being Scarlet or Anna in Hyperion Heights and being divorced from Rogers.

      I definitely don't think Wish Hook would have been involved. Partially because the writers have said he was specifically introduced as a plot device to explain Emma's absence, but also because a lot of the plots with Wish Hook -- specifically with him and Rumple -- seem like they would make a lot more sense if it was OG Hook.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • DatNuttyKid wrote:
      I'm conflicted as to whether or not Alice would have been Emma and Hook's kid because I'm not sure what the timeline would be if she was, but otherwise it seems pretty reasonable.

      Besides that, I still like the idea of Emma being Scarlet or Anna in Hyperion Heights and being divorced from Rogers.

      I definitely don't think Wish Hook would have been involved. Partially because the writers have said he was specifically introduced as a plot device to explain Emma's absence, but also because a lot of the plots with Wish Hook -- specifically with him and Rumple -- seem like they would make a lot more sense if it was OG Hook.

      I see Gothel separating Alice from Hook & Emma and keeping her in the Tower because she is the Guardian, and maybe Gothel was interested in her magic or something. But i don't think the Poisoned Heart storyline would've happened.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Emma would probably be cursed in Hyperion Heights with Hook instead of WHook.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Lady Rapunzel wrote:
      DatNuttyKid wrote:
      I'm conflicted as to whether or not Alice would have been Emma and Hook's kid because I'm not sure what the timeline would be if she was, but otherwise it seems pretty reasonable.

      Besides that, I still like the idea of Emma being Scarlet or Anna in Hyperion Heights and being divorced from Rogers.

      I definitely don't think Wish Hook would have been involved. Partially because the writers have said he was specifically introduced as a plot device to explain Emma's absence, but also because a lot of the plots with Wish Hook -- specifically with him and Rumple -- seem like they would make a lot more sense if it was OG Hook.

      I see Gothel separating Alice from Hook & Emma and keeping her in the Tower because she is the Guardian, and maybe Gothel was interested in her magic or something. But i don't think the Poisoned Heart storyline would've happened.

      100% agree! They could probably have shifted the timeline around to age Alice up (considering tIMe in THe NeF rUNs FAsTer). 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Lady Junky wrote:

      We know that - at the origin - they wanted Colin, Lana, Robert AND JMO to return as series regular for S7.

      Sorry if it is out-of-topic, but Adam & Eddy wanted Ginny and Josh to continue, too. They are the ones who declined, since they had told them that Season 6 would be their last. The only cast members that Adam & Eddy decided would not continue were Bex, Emilie & Jared. 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • Jim OUATcollins wrote:
      Lady Junky wrote:

      We know that - at the origin - they wanted Colin, Lana, Robert AND JMO to return as series regular for S7.

      Sorry if it is out-of-topic, but Adam & Eddy wanted Ginny and Josh to continue, too. They are the ones who declined, since they had told them that Season 6 would be their last. The only cast members that Adam & Eddy decided would not continue were Bex, Emilie & Jared. 

      But Adam and Eddy knew about Ginny and Josh some time in advance -- I think they said they had known for a year. Jennifer was asked back, given a contract, and declined the contract, so removing Emma from the season was more last minute.

      Because Josh and Ginny expressed that they wanted to leave so much earlier, we also don't know if Adam and Eddy would have asked them back or not. I'm inclined to think they wouldn't have because I don't really see where they would have fit in.

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • if Jennifer stayed for season 7, I wonder what Emma cursed counterpart and memories would be like?

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I think, since curses are meant to take happy endings away, that Emma gave birth to her baby, but she got stolen as a baby, things became too much for Emma and she split up with hook, under of finding eloese Gardner, hook is looking for his baby, and in the new world, Emma starts a romance with someone else, maybe like nick (but he turns out evil and dies- like Walsh)

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • I think they would have changed a bit the backstories and make Alice Hook and Emma's daughter! The resemblance is on point! 

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • RickyYG wrote:
      I think they would have changed a bit the backstories and make Alice Hook and Emma's daughter! The resemblance is on point! 

      Exactly

        Preparing Editor Spell
    • A Spy in the Mirror
        Preparing Editor Spell
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message